Ask A Rules Question

Todd Abraham

Todd Abraham

C. Cliff McCrath

C. Cliff McCrath

If you have a question about or need an interpretation of  the NCAA Soccer Rules, you’ve come to the right place. Two NISOA Hall of Famers, long time NCAA Soccer Secretary-Rules Editor, C. Cliff McCrath and NISOA National Rules Interpreter (and current NISOA Senior Director of Instruction) Todd Abraham are active contributors here. Please follow the following guidelines before posting your question:

  • Read the current NCAA Soccer Rules book (available on the Forms page of our site).
  • Do not post questions regarding issues of referee judgement.
  • Do not post specific game details ( i.e. home team, match date, etc.) with your question, if your question happens to be about something you saw during an intercollegiate soccer game.
All questions are subject to editorial review. This is offered as a service to NISOA membership for educational purposes, with the expressed understanding that only the NCAA Soccer Secretary-Rules Editor (Ken Andres) can provide an official rule interpretation.

461 Responses to “Ask A Rules Question”

  1. Red #9, a substitute located off the field of play, throws an object that strikes the head of Blue #3, a player from the opposing team located on the field of play. Red #9, being a team representative, is ejected for fighting ( What is the restart according to the NCAA Soccer Rules?

    The key is, this is a substitute committing the offense.

    If the two are considered “opponents”, then surely 12.1.3 takes precedence and the restart is a direct free-kick or penalty kick.

    However, if a substitute and a player from the opposing team are not by definition “opponents” then 12.2.8 would apply and the restart would be an indirect free-kick.

    If 12.2.8 applies, is the restart from the point of contact, or the position of the ball when play was stopped?

    The larger issue is: IFAB clearly defines the offenses that can be committed by certain individuals, whereas the NCAA Soccer Rules do not. In fact, substitutes are not even specifically mentioned as individuals who can commit a cautionable or ejectable offense in rule 12. As they are participants listed on the game roster, they can be cautioned, but only if one considers them “team representatives” can they be ejected.

    • The restart is an indirect free kick from the place the ball was when the play was stopped. As you have reasoned, 12.2.8 applies. The game is stopped for misconduct (in this case fighting, which requires Red #9 be ejected, the substitute, coach and scorekeeper be notified that the ejection is for fighting and a report is completed on-line indicating Red #9 was ejected for fighting). The restart after the game is stopped to deal with misconduct is an indirect free kick from the spot the ball is at the time, if the ball was in play.

      If the ball was not in play, the restart is whatever restart was going to be when the ball went out of play before the misconduct.

  2. Got this one from a coach I ran into recently…’Can a player wear an Apple Watch in a game?”

    4.2.6 states players can wear a device for the purpose of monitoring/accumulating data, during the game.
    AR 4.3.a May a player wear [types of jewelry], watches, etc? No.

    So should this be wearable technology that is under the uniform? Or is the Apple Watch and like devices that accumulate data allowable?

    • No – all monitoring devices must be worn under their garments and can not be dangerous to the play nor opponents. An Apple watch is not allowed under 4.2.6

  3. Regarding Substitutions
    A player(s) is substituted for a caution, equipment or injury. If the opposing team wants to substitute an equal number, must the opposing player(s) be checked in prior to the stoppage?

  4. I am the clinician for TISOA (Pittsburgh) and recently had an official ask me a question about a coach being ejected. We have several Division 3 schools in our area where the same person coaches the women and men. The question is: if a coach is ejected in the first match of a women’s / men’s double header, are the eligible to coach in the 2nd match of the day?

  5. twice last season at away games a powered amplifier was used to cheer on the home team by spectators in the stands and on the sidelines at CALPAC conference games. I was told by both the home team schools that powered amplifiers were legal to use as there had been a rules change. I don’t know if that is true or that they just did not won’t to enforce the rules. I was unable to find that rule change can you help me ?

    • In the 2019 / 2020 NCAA Rules book identified a change to Rule and .2 which now permits bands, musical instruments and artificial noisemakers at anytime, however, amplified music is still only allowed during the pregame, period intervals and when the clock is stopped and the ball is not in play. The exact question you ask is addressed in A.R. 5.6.9.a. The amplifiers you indicated are limited to those specific instances.

Leave a Reply

Comments are subject to moderation. Comments may be removed at the discretion of the site administrator for any reason, including, but not limited to, failure to provide a valid email address, excessive linking or inappropriate language. Please be aware that if you leave comments on the site, we collect the data shown in the comments form, and also the visitor's IP address and browser user agent string to help spam detection. Please refer to our Privacy Policy for more information about how we manage user data.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.